Is my tax assessment what my house is worth? Assessment is for tax. Not list price.
Assessment is what the city uses for tax. Market value is what a buyer pays. Last 12 months, 1,775 southeast sales with an assessed value sold at about 93.5% of tax assessment.
By Jason Todd, Calgary REALTOR® · Southeast Calgary
“Jason… does this mean my house is worth this now?”
Fair question.
Short answer: no.
Your tax assessment and your home’s market value are not the same thing.
Sometimes they’re close.
Sometimes they’re not.
And one of the easiest ways to show that is to look at what buyers actually paid — the same sold data I use when someone asks me what is my home worth, or when a neighbour’s sale sparks the question from my last Hey Jason piece.
What Is a Tax Assessment?
What Is a Tax Assessment?
Your city assessment exists to help calculate property taxes.
It’s not designed to predict exactly what your home would sell for if you listed tomorrow.
The city doesn’t walk through every renovation.
They don’t know if your basement was finished.
They don’t know if buyers suddenly started preferring your floor plan.
And they definitely don’t know what happened in your exact neighbourhood last month.
Assessments are useful.
But they’re estimates.
Market value is something different.
Market value is what an actual buyer agrees to pay.
What the Data Shows
What the Data Shows
I pulled June 1 – August 15, 2026 detached home sales under $800,000 with tax assessed value on the MLS® record and compared final sold prices to those assessments. A few southeast communities jumped out.
In Mahogany, detached homes sold for an average of 9.2% below assessed value (19 sales). That means a home assessed around $702,000 sold closer to $638,000 on average.
Detached homes sold about 11% below assessed value (7 sales). In McKenzie Towne, the gap was only about 2.7% below (23 sales).
Same city.
Same assessment system.
Different gaps by neighbourhood.
If tax assessments represented exact market value, that shouldn’t happen.
But it does.
Because buyers don’t know what your assessment notice says.
Buyers decide value.
When I expanded the comparison across more southeast Calgary communities, the pattern stayed inconsistent:
Community
Sales (n)
Avg sold vs assessment
Seton
7
−10.9%
Mahogany
19
−9.2%
Auburn Bay
15
−8.4%
McKenzie Towne
23
−2.7%
Seton
Sales (n)7
Avg sold vs assessment−10.9%
Mahogany
Sales (n)19
Avg sold vs assessment−9.2%
Auburn Bay
Sales (n)15
Avg sold vs assessment−8.4%
McKenzie Towne
Sales (n)23
Avg sold vs assessment−2.7%
Source: MLS® sold data, Pillar 9 / CREB®, detached sales under $800,000 with tax assessed value on file, June 1 – August 15, 2026. Figures believed accurate at time of writing; not intended as an appraisal. Not all sold listings include assessed value.
Across these southeast communities, sold prices ran below assessment — but the gap changed a lot by neighbourhood.
That alone tells us assessment isn’t market value.
Want to see how homes in your community actually sold compared to tax assessed value? Send me a message. I’ll pull the data and show you.
So How Do Realtors Figure Out Value?
So How Do Realtors Figure Out Value?
When someone asks me what their home is worth, I don’t start with the assessment.
I start with sold data.
What sold?
How similar was it?
How long did it take?
Did buyers compete?
Did the seller reduce the price?
That’s where the real story is.
I’ve seen homes sell above assessment.
I’ve seen homes sell below assessment.
I’ve seen homes on the same street end up with completely different results.
That’s why I spend more time looking at sold properties than active listings — and why pricing strategy matters as much as picking the right comp, as I covered in my piece on Cranston and Mahogany days on market.
Jason’s Take
I answer this from sold data, not a blog average.
I wouldn’t ignore your tax assessment.
But I also wouldn’t use it to decide your list price.
Think of it as one piece of information.
Not the answer.
Your home’s value today depends on buyer demand, competition, condition, pricing strategy, and what similar homes have actually sold for recently.
The market decides value.
Not the envelope.
FAQ
Is my tax assessment what my house is worth — common questions
Is my tax assessment what my house is worth?
No. Your assessment helps the city calculate property taxes. Market value is what a buyer actually pays — and in June 1 – August 15, 2026, Mahogany detached sales under $800,000 averaged about 9.2% below assessment while Seton averaged about 11% below.
Why did my neighbour’s assessment change but mine didn’t?
Assessments reflect the city’s mass-appraisal model and timing, not a walk-through of each home. Upgrades, lot position, and recent sales in your pocket can all move market value without matching the assessment line on your notice.
Can I use my assessment to set my list price?
I wouldn’t. List price should come from recent sold comps, days on market, and buyer demand in your community — not the number on your tax notice.
How do I find out what my Calgary home is actually worth?
Notices typically arrive in the spring or early summer each year. The assessed value on your notice reflects the city’s valuation cycle — not a live snapshot of what your home would sell for today.
Source: MLS® sold records (Pillar 9 / CREB®). Jason Todd, Calgary REALTOR®.
IDX for personal, non-commercial use to identify properties. Listing content is owned by the listing brokerage. Asking prices shown; sold prices on request. MLS® and REALTOR® are trademarks. Pillar 9 / CREB®. Not legal advice.